On 12 June 2026, the Court of First Instance of Antwerp issued a remarkable judgement confirming the application of the Belgian Cayman Tax to a Luxembourg partnership (“SCS”).
According to the Court, the Luxemburg SCS qualifies as a “hybrid entity”, which is a type of “legal construction” (“construction juridique”/”juridische constructie”) falling within the scope of the Cayman tax.
1️⃣ Why is the SCS an hybrid entity ?
🔸 The “Cayman Tax” is a look-through tax applicable to Belgian resident individuals who are the “founders” of a “legal construction”.
🔸 From a Luxembourg tax perspective, the Luxemburg SCS (“société en commandite simple”) is treated as tax transparent with respect to Luxembourg corporate income tax (“CIT”) and net worth tax (“NWT”) (but not for municipal business tax purposes).
🔸 From a Belgian tax viewpoint, the SCS is however treated as “opaque”, as it has legal personality according to Luxembourg company law.
🔸 Such hybrid entities may qualify as a “legal construction” (subject to Cayman Tax), unless the Belgian individual shareholder is able to demonstrate that he is actually subject in Luxembourg to a minimal taxation threshold of 1%. In the case at hand, the taxpayer was unable to provide such evidence.
2️⃣ Substance exclusion
🔸 The taxpayer tried to avoid the Cayman Tax by invoking the so-called “substance exclusion”. This escape route aims at ensuring that the Cayman Tax (look-through taxation) only targets artificial arrangements, rather than legitimate foreign entites with real economic substance.
🔸 The taxpayer failed however to demonstrate that the SCS maintained a proportionate set of premises, staff, and equipment on-site that directly supported its economic activity.
3️⃣ The significant risks of Luxembourg entities (held by Belgian tax residents) lacking sufficient substance
🔸 The Court held the shareholder of the SCS liable to pay personal income taxes of approx. 400k EUR pursuant to the Cayman tax regime for the 2021 and 2022 tax years. It also imposed a tax increase of 50%, as the taxpayer had set up the Luxembourg structure with the clear intent to evade tax in Belgium.
☀️ In another recent ruling of the Court of appeal of Ghent dated 3 March 2026, the use of a Luxemburg SCS -lacking sufficient substance- by a Belgian individual was also challenged based on another reasoning (the SCS was subject to CIT in Belgium, as its seat of management was located in Belgium). I refer in this respect to my previous post ([1]).
🔅 The taxpayer had also attempted to avoid the Cayman tax by arguing that it was not compliant with the Belgian-Luxembourg DTT. I will touch on this hot topic in my next post. Stay tuned!
Denis-Emmanuel Philippe
[1] Jurisprudence fiscale : les pièges liés à l’utilisation d’une société luxembourgeoise sans substance (Cour d’appel de Gand, arrêts du 3 mars 2026 et du 21 avril 2026) – Quand les conséquences fiscales s’étendent au domaine de la TVA! | Denis-Emmanuel Philippe
